No Subway Rider Would Have Found Daniel Penny Guilty 40 Years Ago

Subway Vigilantes: Past and Present

Forty years ago, in the bustling subways of New York, the atmosphere was significantly different. Back then, there was the notorious Subway Vigilante, and any subway rider witnessing the actions of Marine Daniel Penny would not have found him guilty in the chokehold death of a man who posed a serious threat to others. In those days, many would have questioned the absence of police officers and good Samaritans willing to intervene when danger arose. Should we allow a man to attack or intimidate citizens who are simply going about their daily lives?

The defense attorney Barry Slotnick famously won the case for Bernie Goetz, a man who faced similar circumstances when defending himself against a threatening situation. The conclusion then, as it is now, remains: well done for those who stand up against violence.

The Role of Society in Safety

Today, we must reflect on society's role in ensuring safety in public spaces like subways. What happens when individuals feel the need to take the law into their own hands? In a world where citizens feel vulnerable, the lines between right and wrong can become blurred. The community often looks towards police and good-hearted individuals for assistance when situations escalate, yet the lack of immediate support can lead people to act out.

The tragic events surrounding Daniel Penny's actions highlight a significant issue: the responsibility of bystanders to help those in need and the failure of law enforcement to maintain order. A situation where a man threatens fellow passengers should not go unchecked. It raises the question—what can we do to ensure that citizens feel safe while also empowering them to react appropriately in dangerous situations?

justice, safety, society